Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Chris Smaje's avatar

Short answer to James's question is that livestock don't create fertility, so yes it's possible to do without manure - but livestock do help to cycle fertility and tap additional sources and in low energy societies without livestock that would mean a lot of work for human hands, so James's leisure question is to the point.

Simon Fairlie's book 'Meat: A Benign Extravagance' published in 2010 is still IMO the best work through of these issues. A few things have changed but it stands the test of time. One thing that's moved on a bit is the question of methane and livestock methane emissions - frankly, 'The Guardian', mentioned above, is on an anti-livestock tirade that's getting a lot of things wrong, notably on the methane issue. My book 'Saying NO to a Farm-Free Future', out soon, examines this point among others.

Expand full comment
karen rom's avatar

Slow food for the soul and brain. It's so healthy to hear about efforts like yours. And be present at Steve's 'conversion'. This is how it's done....

Curious about the Peasantry School, as well as its newsletter???

Thank you; I appreciate how much time and effort you are making over your regular work to write about it. It's appreciated.

Expand full comment
26 more comments...

No posts